Humboldt County’s planning director says the use permit for Miranda’s Rescue in Fortuna is suspended, and it will stay suspended until the rescue meets the conditions the county set when it approved the permit.
“Suspension will not be lifted until operation complies with conditions of approval,” John Ford, director of the county’s Planning and Building Department, told the Wine Country Gazette in an email Tuesday.
Napa County’s animal shelter sent 113 dogs to the rescue from January 2018 to March 30 of this year, according to the shelter’s own transfer report, released under the California Public Records Act. Every one is listed as going out for “Adoption/Rehoming.” The last eight left a month before Humboldt County sheriff’s detectives served a search warrant at the rescue on May 1. In June they came back to dig.
More than six months after the first warrant, no charges have been announced. On Nov. 13, Sheriff William Honsal posted an update to say his office and its state and federal partners are still working. “This investigation is not over,” he wrote.
What investigators found
The Sheriff’s Office says it got the allegations on April 22: felony animal abuse, animal cruelty, fraud and conspiracy at the rescue, at 1603 Sandy Prairie Road.
The second warrant was served June 23. When the digging ended June 25, investigators had recovered 117 intact dog remains from two sites, plus 21 more skulls, hundreds of bones and six loose microchips, the office said in a June 26 release. Seventy of the dogs were X-rayed on site, and many showed bullet fragments. Based on exams by USDA and forensic veterinarians, investigators preliminarily found that many of those 70 died of gunshot wounds. In a barn, investigators found more than 600 dog collars, in an area they believe is where the dogs were likely killed.
The FBI, the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the state Department of Justice, the California Attorney General’s Office and the Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office are all part of the case.
Shannon Miranda, who runs the rescue, has denied criminal wrongdoing. He told investigators he shot animals “to prevent suffering,” according to the warrant affidavit unsealed in May.
‘Not prepared to discuss’ charges
Honsal’s Nov. 13 statement says that neither the Sheriff’s Office “nor any of our state and federal partner agencies has concluded its investigation.”
“While we had hoped the investigation would be completed by now, it is not,” it says. “At this time, we are not prepared to discuss specific evidence, investigative findings or potential criminal charges.”
In June the office said that if the evidence supports charges, the case will go to prosecutors to decide. Neither the Sheriff’s Office nor the District Attorney’s Office has announced an arrest or charges. The sheriff’s statement says the office’s job “is to seek justice based on the evidence, not to try a case in the court of public opinion.”
What the county’s permit file shows
The rescue’s Humboldt County use permit, number CUP-02-09, dates to the early 2000s, according to county permit records.
The county’s online permit file logs a staff task, completed Sept. 15, to prepare a notice that the permit was “unsuspended,” meaning taken off suspension. Ford said Tuesday that the permit is suspended now. He didn’t say when the current suspension began.
The same file logs a Sept. 17 phone call with Allison Jackson, a partner at Harland Law Firm. On Sept. 22, it logs staff conferring with the county’s chief building official, the department director and the planning manager, and preparing an email of findings for Jackson. Ford confirmed that Jackson represents Miranda and the rescue on the permit.
On Oct. 27, a pre-application listing Miranda as the property owner was filed with the county. It asks to “permit and elevate” the rescue’s cat building “due to Flood Zone” and to permit fencing along the front property line. On Nov. 2 the county marked it as needing more information.
Other county records tied to the rescue are still open. A code enforcement case opened June 16 over “Unpermitted Structures/Modifications” is listed as an “Active Investigation.” A May 27 complaint to county environmental health over sewage and water systems is listed as “Referred – Non-Jurisdictional.”
Charity registration ‘Past Due’
Miranda’s Rescue is still listed as “Registered” with the California Attorney General’s Registry of Charities and Fundraisers. Its reporting status reads “Past Due,” which the registry defines as having an annual report that is past due.
Mendocino and Congress
Mendocino County’s shelter sent dogs to the rescue, too. Kennel cards released through a 2017 county records request show two dogs transferred to “MIRANDA RESCUE” in Fortuna that year: Mercury, a German shepherd mix, on Jan. 17, and Clayton, a Labrador retriever mix, on Feb. 2.
In Washington, Rep. James Gallagher, R-Calif., introduced Dunkin’s Law on Oct. 26, pointing to the dogs found at Miranda’s. It would let owners sue commercial pet-care businesses, like boarding kennels and groomers, when a pet is hurt, neglected or killed in their care. It would also create a path to civil accountability for rescues and shelters convicted of unlawfully euthanizing pets under state or local law.
“People entrusted these animals to a rescue believing they would be protected, only for authorities to discover more than a hundred dead dogs buried on the property,” Gallagher said in a release. The bill is named for Dunkin, a dog who died after his owners left him at a boarding facility. The release says the bill would apply only going forward and wouldn’t decide liability in the Miranda’s case.
Napa’s transfer report lists the eight dogs that left on March 30 by ID number. It’s a list of transfers out, not of what happened to the dogs after they arrived.
Get the Gazette by email
The day’s stories from Sonoma, Napa, Lake and Mendocino counties, picked by the editor. Free.