Sonoma County supervisors approved $500,000 Tuesday to start planning a fix or replacement for the Guerneville building that holds the lower Russian River’s sheriff’s substation. A 24-hour homeless shelter runs in the same building.
The vote was 4-0. Board Chair Rebecca Hermosillo was absent. The money is one line in a $36.1 million package of one-time spending in the county’s fall budget update. It needed four votes to pass.
Before the vote, Supervisor Lynda Hopkins, who represents the lower river, asked what the money would buy. She wanted to know “just to sort of set expectations for the community.” Sheriff Eddie Engram answered first.
“At times at that substation prior to 2016, we would have four deputy sheriffs on staff, on duty at a time, and now it’s been reduced to two,” Engram said, according to the county’s meeting video. “So it is definitely a challenge in providing rapid service to that area.”
The river zone is hard to cover, he said. Deputies there have to use “typically two-lane roads, small roads, roads that we can’t traverse very quickly.”
5 or 6 sites
An assistant county executive told the board the county has been looking for a new home for the substation.
“Over the last year I think we’ve looked at five, maybe six different potential sites for a new sheriff’s substation, whether it be a temporary facility until a permanent one was built, or partnering with other agencies,” the assistant county executive said. “We’re still exploring which one is the best fit.”
The $500,000 means money is “available and ready to go to start design and moving them into a new space,” the official said. That way, staff can bring the board a long-term plan “as opposed to having to continue to kind of piecemeal every phase,” the assistant county executive said.
In 2025, county staff wrote that a study had found the preferred site “remains the current location,” because the First Street lot is “among the last areas in the Guerneville area to flood during major rain events.” Staff put the planning and design job at $750,000. They put a new building at $10 million to $12 million, “subject to change.” No money was set aside then.
A building more than 100 years old
The Guerneville Veterans Building, as the county calls it, is at 16255 First St. Engram said the county can trace it back more than 100 years. The roof isn’t leaking now, he said.
A 2019 engineering report, which WCG obtained through a public records request, found the ground under the building is “highly susceptible to liquefaction.” Settling in a quake “will likely render the building un-occupiable,” it says.
Hopkins said she and the sheriff had both visited “when there was literally plastic tarps taped to the ceiling, which had asbestos on the other side of them.”
West County Community Services runs the shelter there under a county license. Hopkins called it “the only 24/7, 365” shelter in Guerneville and the “only unincorporated shelter in west county.”
“There’s nowhere else to go if and when that building, knock on wood, gets red-tagged, because we know it’s only a matter of time and we’ve narrowly avoided that in past floods,” she said.
She asked staff to use the work Praxis Architects of Monte Rio has already done for the county, so they’re “not duplicating any efforts.”
The rest of the package
The list of approved spending includes $11 million to repair storm-damaged roads, among them Harrison Grade and Mill Creek. It also has $8 million to start updating the main jail and $4 million to design the Asti Bridge.
The county is spending only one-time money. Its forecast shows a general fund gap of $8.1 million in the 2027-28 budget year. The gap grows to $50.8 million by 2031-32 if nothing changes.
The fall budget report doesn’t say when a design for the Guerneville site, or a new one, would come back to the board.
Safety in town
Hopkins said Guerneville has had two community meetings on “substantial public safety concerns.” The sheriff came to the town’s municipal advisory council last week, she said.
At the first of those meetings, she said, a business owner from the Guerneville Plaza “literally brought cans of pepper spray to hand out to her colleagues.”
There are only so many deputies, Hopkins said. If they’re called to another part of the area, such as Cazadero, “it takes them a while to get back.”
“We never have recovered in terms of the sheriff’s office from pre-recession staffing,” she said. She said she hopes the board takes that up in future budget hearings.
Get the Gazette by email
The day’s stories from Sonoma, Napa, Lake and Mendocino counties, picked by the editor. Free.