Fifty of the 137 people who work for Lake County Sheriff Luke Bingham got the wrong paycheck from the county’s new Workday system, he told supervisors Tuesday. One was underpaid by $1,500. Another was short $3,000.
Supervisors then voted 4-0 to start going back to the old computer system Workday was bought to replace, called Naviline, and run both systems side by side while Workday gets fixed. This month’s payroll stays in Workday. The county isn’t dropping Workday.
“I’m just speaking for my employees that the current payroll system is not working,” Bingham said.
The vote came after more than an hour of testimony from department heads, fire district staff and the county’s school chief. They described wrong paychecks, bills going unpaid and cash balances no department could reliably check.
What went wrong
Workday went live Oct. 1. By Oct. 20, a county memo listed direct deposit among its “known issues,” and supervisors approved paper paychecks as a backup if direct deposit still didn’t work by Oct. 26.
Behavioral Health Director Elise Jones said lease payments that used to go out through the old system have become late or uneven. Her department now faces more than $600 in late fees. She said the local money the county must put up to draw down Medi-Cal dollars “is presently at a standstill.”
The agricultural commissioner said some vendors had gone two months without being paid. Two of them will probably wait three months, the commissioner said.
Fire districts’ money runs through the county’s system too. A financial analyst for the Lake County Fire Protection District said almost $300,000 in checks written by Kelseyville Fire was posted to her district’s account by mistake.
Lake County Superintendent of Schools Brock Falkenberg said school districts have the same problems. He said he had asked supervisors before the switch to delay it six months.
Treasurer-Tax Collector Patrick Sullivan said the cash balances in Workday are unreliable. “There does not appear to be a way right now that any department or district can reliably check its cash balance,” he said.
He called a return to Naviline “the safest course of action.”
The auditor’s side
Auditor-Controller Jenavive Herrington, who brought the Workday contract to the board, argued against going back. She said new systems normally take about six months to settle in, and Lake County was 47 days in.
Herrington said most payroll errors came from departments approving wrong hours. Two came from how the system was set up, and both have been fixed, she said. Her office has emailed workers who were overpaid about paying it back.
“It will take a lot more work to try to go back than it will be to complete the project,” Herrington said.
Human Resources Director Pam Samac said going back means putting seven weeks of data into the old system, with payroll work starting in five days. Chief Deputy Auditor-Controller Sara Barajas said the payroll staff is three people, including her.
What it cost
The county signed its Workday software contract in January 2025 for $4,192,452, running through January 2035. A separate statement of work attached to the contract set $2,371,320 for Workday to set the system up. On Sept. 15, supervisors added $175,000 to push the start date to Oct. 1.
Sullivan said Naviline’s maker is phasing it out, and he still wants the county off it. The county’s January 2025 memo said it hadn’t looked for a new finance system in more than 20 years.
Assistant County Administrative Officer Stephen Carter recommended a contract of about $74,000 for outside experts to help the auditor’s office with payroll. Sabatier said contracts tied to the switch should go to the board’s Workday committee.
What happens next
Supervisor Bruno Sabatier, who sits on the board’s Workday committee with Vice Chair Jessica Pyska, made the motion.
“I think it starts with us at the top when we agreed to moving forward with this in the first place and not setting up our guardrails and our checklist of what needed to occur before we moved forward,” Sabatier said.
Sabatier said guidance on the switch will come out of the committee’s meeting Friday. The committee is supposed to report to the board every two weeks.
Get the Gazette by email
The day’s stories from Sonoma, Napa, Lake and Mendocino counties, picked by the editor. Free.