People who insure Lake County homes through the California FAIR Plan face higher bills at renewal, about $693 more a year per policy on average, the plan projects.
The FAIR Plan sells basic fire coverage to people who can’t get it from a regular insurer. Its new rates apply to policies that start or renew on or after Oct. 15. “Existing policies transition to the new rates at their next renewal on or after that date,” the plan said in an Oct. 20 emailed statement.
The plan’s approved rate filing with the California Department of Insurance projects what its policies would pay under the new rates, ZIP code by ZIP code. For the 5,206 Lake County policies it counted in March 2025, premiums rise from about $15.3 million a year to about $18.9 million, up 23.6%. The average Lake policy goes from about $2,942 to $3,635.
Statewide, the filing’s ZIP code table shows a 29% increase.
Where the increases land
The largest percentage increases among Lake County ZIP codes with more than 40 policies:
- Glenhaven: 40.4%, on 43 policies
- Lucerne: 39.1%, on 249 policies
- Nice: 36.8%, on 171 policies
- Hidden Valley Lake: 35.3%, on 352 policies, about $1,158 more a policy
- Cobb: 34.9%, on 398 policies, about $1,054 more a policy
- Clearlake: 33.7%, on 755 policies, about $567 more a policy
- Clearlake Oaks: 30.2%, on 340 policies
Kelseyville has the most FAIR Plan policies in the county, 1,339 in the filing. Its premiums rise 19.9%, about $739 a policy. Lakeport rises 21.5%, Middletown 19.3% and Lower Lake 13.1%. Upper Lake rises 3.3%. In Witter Springs, where the plan had 17 policies, premiums drop 7.3%.
The filing also lists the largest dollar increase it projects for any one policy in each ZIP code. In Kelseyville it’s $4,864. In Glenhaven it’s $4,725, in Clearlake Oaks $4,533 and in Lakeport $4,469.
These are the plan’s projections for the policies it had in March 2025, not actual bills. A bill depends on the property, the coverage it carries and changes to the amount it’s insured for.
Why rates went up
The Department of Insurance approved the increase April 6, according to its list of approved rate filings. The FAIR Plan had asked for an average of 35.6%. The department approved 29.1%.
“The largest component of the approved rate change is tied to wildfire risk, meaning customers with properties facing greater wildfire exposure may experience larger increases, while others may see smaller increases or, in some cases, premium decreases,” the plan said in its statement.
“The FAIR Plan is required by state law to maintain rates that are sufficient to cover expected claims and operating expenses,” it said.
More Lake homes on the plan
The plan has grown in Lake County in each of the last five years, its county figures show. It had 6,251 Lake County policies, homes and businesses together, on Sept. 30, according to those county figures. That’s up 9% from 5,739 a year earlier, and up from 2,230 in 2022.
The Lakeport ZIP code had 84 FAIR Plan home policies in 2022 and 564 this year, according to the plan’s ZIP code figures. Clearlake went from 202 to 939. Kelseyville went from 769 to 1,514.
Before the new rates took effect, Lake County’s 6,089 FAIR Plan home policies carried about $18.2 million in premiums as of Sept. 30, an average of about $2,993 a policy. The statewide average was about $2,731.
“As more insurers have declined to provide new coverage or renew existing policies, more Californians have turned to the California FAIR Plan for the basic property coverage they need,” the plan says on its website.
All 13 California ZIP codes the plan’s latest premium report lists under Lake County are marked as distressed areas. The Department of Insurance uses that label for places where wildfire is a threat, regular insurers have cut back and FAIR Plan policies have piled up, according to its FAQ on distressed areas.
Discounts
The plan offers discounts for homes made harder for fire to damage. “Eligible dwelling policyholders who qualify for all 12 available discounts may receive up to 16.4% off the wildfire portion of their premium,” the plan said.
That’s 16.4% off the wildfire part of the bill, not the whole bill. “The amount of savings depends on the discounts for which the property qualifies and the wildfire portion of the policy’s premium,” the plan said.
The FAIR Plan’s phone number is 800-339-4099.
Get the Gazette by email
The day’s stories from Sonoma, Napa, Lake and Mendocino counties, picked by the editor. Free.